contrast the treatment of Native Americans at most missions with how one would expect the missionaries to treat others.
History · Middle School · Wed Jan 13 2021
Answered on
The treatment of Native Americans at most missions was often marked by a complex mix of cultural assimilation, forced labor, and significant challenges to their traditional ways of life. Here's a brief contrast between the treatment of Native Americans at missions and the ideal expectations one might have for missionary interactions:
Treatment at Missions:
1. Forced Assimilation:
- *Description:* Native Americans were often forced to adopt European customs, including language, clothing, and religious practices.
- *Impact:* This led to the erosion of indigenous cultures and traditions as Native Americans were compelled to conform to European ways.
2. Labor and Exploitation:
- *Description:* Many Native Americans were subjected to forced labor, working in fields, constructing buildings, or performing other tasks for the missions.
- *Impact:* This contributed to the exploitation of Native American labor and the disruption of their traditional economies.
3. Disease and Decline:
- *Description:* The introduction of European diseases, to which Native Americans had little immunity, led to widespread epidemics.
- *Impact:* Populations at the missions often experienced significant declines due to the devastating effects of diseases.
Expectations for Missionaries:
1. Cultural Respect:
- *Expectation:* Missionaries would ideally respect and appreciate the existing cultural diversity of the Native American communities.
- *Ideal Impact:* Missionaries would work to understand and integrate aspects of the indigenous culture into their teachings, fostering mutual respect.
2. Educational Collaboration:
- *Expectation:* Missionaries could be expected to share knowledge while also learning from the Native American communities.
- *Ideal Impact:* Collaboration would lead to a sharing of ideas and a mutual enrichment of cultural and educational practices.
3. Healthcare Assistance:
- *Expectation:* Missionaries might provide healthcare assistance, aiming to improve the overall well-being of the Native American populations.
- *Ideal Impact:* This support would enhance the health and vitality of the communities without causing harm through unintentional transmission of diseases.
In reality, historical accounts often reveal a more complex and problematic interaction between missionaries and Native Americans, with instances of both positive and negative impacts on indigenous populations. It's important to consider historical contexts and variations in missionary practices across different regions and periods.