Why did Congress create an expanded federal court system?

History · High School · Tue Nov 03 2020

Answered on

 Congress created an expanded federal court system as a response to the needs of a growing nation and to address the limitations of the original judicial framework established by the United States Constitution. The Constitution had set up the Supreme Court as the highest federal court, but it allowed Congress to create lower federal courts as needed.

The Judiciary Act of 1789 was the first major legislative act by Congress to establish an expanded federal court system. It created the basic three-tiered structure of the federal judiciary, which includes district courts at the lowest level, circuit courts in the middle, and the Supreme Court at the top. Here are the reasons for the creation of this expanded court system:

1. Case Load: The Supreme Court alone could not handle the growing number of federal cases. An expanded court system with district and circuit courts allowed for a division of labor, where lower courts could resolve less significant matters, while the Supreme Court would handle appeals and cases of great importance.

2. Geographic Reach: As the United States expanded westward, it became apparent that a single court located in the capital would be unable to serve the legal needs of citizens spread across vast distances. Lower courts were established throughout the country to make the federal judiciary accessible to more people.

3. Specialization: Different types of cases, such as maritime law, required specialized knowledge. An expanded federal judiciary could include courts dedicated to specific areas of law, allowing for more expert judgments in those fields.

4. Enforcement of Federal Laws: An expanded judiciary was necessary to ensure the uniform interpretation and enforcement of federal laws across all states, which helped maintain a cohesive national legal system.

5. Checks and Balances: By creating a multi-tiered judiciary, Congress provided a system of checks and balances within the judicial branch itself, with the higher courts reviewing the decisions of the lower courts.

The expanded federal court system is a cornerstone of the American legal system, ensuring justice is accessible, efficiently administered, and consistent with the Constitution.