What do the following phrases suggest about Beveridge’s view of Americans as compared with people of other nations? - "noble land that God has given us" - "applies only to those who are capable of self-government" - "civilization is dawning, at last, for them"

History · College · Sun Jan 24 2021

Answered on

These phrases from Beveridge's statements suggest a perspective that sees Americans in a favorable light compared to people of other nations. Let's break down each phrase:


  1. "Noble land that God has given us": This expression conveys a sense of national pride and exceptionalism. By describing the land as "noble" and as a gift from God, Beveridge implies a belief in the inherent worthiness and uniqueness of the American nation. This sentiment reflects a form of patriotism that sees the United States as a special and favored entity.
  2. "Applies only to those who are capable of self-government": This phrase implies a selective view of governance. Beveridge suggests that the principles and benefits of the noble land are applicable only to those who are capable of self-government. This implies a belief that Americans possess a unique capability for self-rule, contrasting them with people in other nations who may not be considered as capable of governing themselves.
  3. "Civilization is dawning, at last, for them": This statement implies a sense of progress and enlightenment. The use of the phrase "at last" suggests that, in Beveridge's view, certain nations or groups of people are finally entering a phase of civilization. This could be interpreted as a paternalistic view, with the implication that the progress and enlightenment are being brought to these people, possibly by the more advanced and self-governing nation (in this case, the United States).


Overall, these phrases collectively suggest a perspective that places Americans in a favorable and exceptional position, viewing them as recipients of a noble land, capable of self-government, and serving as harbingers of civilization to others. This viewpoint is characteristic of a form of nationalism that emphasizes the uniqueness and superiority of one's own nation.

Related Questions