Is access to a good healthcare a right? Justify your answer.

Geography · Middle School · Thu Feb 04 2021

Answered on

The question of whether access to good healthcare is a right is not only a philosophical one but also a matter of public policy that varies from country to country. To address this, we need to distinguish between legal rights, moral rights, and human rights.

1. Legal Rights: If a right is legally recognized by a country's laws or international agreements, citizens in that country have a legally enforceable claim to it. For instance, some countries have laws that guarantee their citizens the right to access healthcare services.

2. Moral Rights: These are based on ethical principles rather than legal ones. From a moral standpoint, many argue that healthcare is a fundamental right because it is essential to maintaining a minimum standard of living and allowing people to function in society.

3. Human Rights: Internationally, there are declarations and covenants (such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights) that identify access to healthcare as a basic human right. However, the enforcement and interpretation of these rights can vary greatly.

Advocates for healthcare as a right usually justify their position by arguing that a healthy population is vital for a prosperous and functional society, and that access to healthcare is necessary for the equal opportunity to pursue life goals. Additionally, they suggest that societies have a moral obligation to care for the sick and vulnerable among them.

Critics might argue that referring to healthcare as a "right" might lead to inefficiencies in how healthcare is provided, or that it could burden others with the costs associated with fulfilling this right.