How do the ethical principles and ontology of the bhagavad gita differ from those of the torah?

Social Studies · College · Mon Jan 18 2021

Answered on

The Bhagavad Gita and the Torah are both ancient religious texts that serve as moral and spiritual guides for their respective followers. The ethical principles and ontological views presented within each of these texts reflect the differing cultural, philosophical, and religious contexts in which they were written.

Ethical Principles: 1. Duty and Righteousness: The Bhagavad Gita emphasizes the concept of "dharma," or duty, which is tied to one's role and caste in society. The Gita instructs individuals to fulfill their dharma without attachment to the results. This sense of duty is embodied by the protagonist, Arjuna, who is guided by Krishna to perform his duty as a warrior without succumbing to personal moral dilemmas regarding the battlefield.

2. Renunciation: The Gita also introduces the idea of renunciation of the fruits of actions, where one should act without desire for personal gain or fear of loss, something that is referred to as "Nishkama Karma."

3. Unity with the Divine: The Gita's ethical vision is also intimately connected to its ontology, it encourages devotion to God (Bhakti), through which one can achieve union with the divine, ultimate reality, or "Brahman."

In contrast:

1. Law and Covenant: The Torah, particularly in its first five books (the Pentateuch), focuses on the laws given by God to the people of Israel. These laws constitute a covenant between God and the Jewish people where moral and ritual laws dictate the ethical behavior required by God.

2. Community and Justice: The ethical principles in the Torah are often communal and justice-oriented. There is a strong emphasis on social justice, helping the poor, and treating strangers with kindness because of the Israelites' own history as strangers.

Ontology: 1. The Bhagavad Gita presents an ontology that is deeply spiritual and philosophical. It proposes that the ultimate reality is Brahman, and that every soul, or "Atman," is fundamentally an extension of this universal essence. It speaks of the universe in cyclical terms and places emphasis on the transcendence of the cycle of birth and rebirth (samsara) through spiritual realization.

2. The Torah's ontology is more historical and linear, focusing on the one God who created the world and chose a particular people, the Israelites, to have a special relationship with. It discusses life and the material world as created by God, with less focus on the cycle of reincarnation and more on living in accordance with God's will to uphold the covenant.

Related Questions