during the late 1800s nativist promoted the idea that immigrants contributed to unemployment by

History · College · Mon Jan 18 2021

Answered on

During the late 1800s in the United States, nativists promoted the idea that immigrants contributed to unemployment by advancing several arguments, some of which were based on economic concerns and others rooted in cultural and social prejudices. Key arguments included:


1. Economic Competition:

  • Nativists argued that the influx of immigrants created intense competition for jobs, particularly in industries and sectors where labor was in demand. They contended that immigrants, willing to work for lower wages, undercut the economic interests of native-born workers.

2. Fear of Job Displacement:

  • Nativists expressed concern that immigrants were taking jobs away from native-born workers. They often portrayed immigrants as willing to accept lower wages and inferior working conditions, making it difficult for native workers to secure employment.

3. Cultural and Racial Biases:

  • Cultural and racial biases played a significant role in nativist arguments. Some nativists believed that certain immigrant groups were culturally inferior or racially unfit for American society. This prejudice contributed to the perception that immigrants were undesirable and posed a threat to the economic well-being of the nation.

4. Social Darwinism:

  • The late 19th century saw the influence of Social Darwinism, a theory that applied principles of natural selection to human society. Nativists, influenced by Social Darwinism, argued that restricting immigration was a way to preserve the perceived racial and cultural superiority of the existing population.

5. Labor Union Concerns:

  • Some labor unions supported nativist sentiments due to concerns about the impact of immigration on the bargaining power of workers. They feared that an oversupply of labor would weaken the ability of unions to negotiate for better wages and working conditions.


These nativist sentiments led to the implementation of restrictive immigration policies, such as the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and the Immigration Act of 1924. These laws were aimed at limiting the entry of specific immigrant groups, reflecting nativist fears and prejudices.

It's important to note that these nativist arguments were not universally accepted, and there were individuals and groups advocating for the rights and fair treatment of immigrants. The nativist sentiments of the late 19th century were complex and intertwined with economic, social, and racial dynamics shaping American society during that period.