Discuss Dewey's approach to understanding experience using Heidegger's conception of mind and body and any relation to Heidegger's approach to ontology? In what way does Husserl's concept of ontology relate to the ideas of Dewey and Heidegger?

Social Studies · College · Wed Jan 13 2021

Answered on

John Dewey, Martin Heidegger, and Edmund Husserl were influential philosophers in the 20th century, each contributing distinct perspectives to the realms of philosophy, ontology, and the nature of experience.

Dewey's Approach to Experience:

Dewey, a pragmatist philosopher, focused on the significance of experience in shaping human understanding and knowledge. He emphasized the continuity of experience, where the mind and body are inseparable in the ongoing process of engagement with the environment. Dewey's instrumentalist perspective suggested that mind and body dynamically interact within the context of experience, with cognition evolving through an ongoing transaction with the environment.

Heidegger's Conception of Mind and Body:

Heidegger, drawing on existential and phenomenological traditions, rejected Cartesian dualism and offered an alternative perspective. He emphasized the concept of "being-in-the-world," where the mind and body are not separate entities but integral aspects of our existence. In Heidegger's ontology, the human experience is rooted in our engagement with the world, and understanding arises from our situatedness within a context rather than abstract reflection.

Relation to Heidegger's Approach to Ontology:

Heidegger's ontology is closely tied to his emphasis on understanding being in the context of our lived experiences. He rejected traditional metaphysics and sought to uncover the fundamental structures of human existence. Heidegger's focus on the ontological aspects of being aligns with his emphasis on the lived experience as the foundation for understanding existence.

Husserl's Concept of Ontology:

Husserl, the founder of phenomenology, approached ontology through a rigorous examination of consciousness and intentional experiences. His method involved suspending assumptions about the external world to focus solely on the phenomenon itself. While Dewey and Heidegger emphasized the embeddedness of the mind and body in the world, Husserl's phenomenology aimed to explore the nature of consciousness and its intentional objects.

In summary, Dewey's pragmatism, Heidegger's existential phenomenology, and Husserl's phenomenology each provide unique perspectives on the relationship between mind, body, and ontology. While Dewey emphasizes the continuity of experience, Heidegger rejects dualism and highlights the lived experience as foundational to ontology. Husserl, on the other hand, explores ontology through a meticulous examination of consciousness and intentional experiences.

Related Questions