A trait, such as height, has high heritability because much of the variation between individuals is the result of genetic variation. however, not all of the variation for height in a population can be attributed to genetic variation alone. why does genetic variation not always determine the differences in a given trait between individuals?

Biology · College · Thu Feb 04 2021

Answered on

While heritability plays a significant role in determining the variation of traits between individuals, it's important to recognize that not all variation in a trait can be attributed to genetic factors alone. Several reasons contribute to the fact that genetic variation does not always entirely determine the differences in a given trait between individuals:

1.Environmental Influence:

Environmental factors, including nutrition, exposure to toxins, socioeconomic conditions, and access to healthcare, can have a substantial impact on trait expression. These environmental influences can contribute to variations in traits even among individuals with similar genetic backgrounds.

2.Gene-Environment Interactions:

The interaction between genetic factors and the environment is crucial. Certain traits may be influenced by a combination of genetic predisposition and specific environmental conditions. For example, an individual's height may be influenced by both genetic factors and nutrition during childhood.

3.Epigenetics:

Epigenetic modifications can affect gene expression without altering the underlying DNA sequence. Environmental factors can induce epigenetic changes, influencing how genes are turned on or off and contributing to trait variation.

4.Random Mutations:

Random mutations that occur during DNA replication can introduce new genetic variations. These mutations can contribute to trait differences, and their occurrence is not entirely predictable based on heritability.

5.Complex Traits and Polygenicity:

Many traits, especially complex ones like intelligence or certain diseases, are polygenic, meaning they are influenced by multiple genes. The interaction of numerous genes and their variants, combined with environmental factors, adds complexity to trait variation.

6.Gene Expression and Regulation:

Differences in gene expression and regulation can influence trait variation. Even if individuals share the same genes, variations in how these genes are expressed can lead to differences in trait manifestation.

7.Stochastic Processes:

Stochastic or random processes in development and biology can contribute to trait variation. Small, random events during development can lead to differences in the final phenotype.

In summary, while heritability provides insights into the proportion of trait variation attributed to genetic factors in a particular population, it does not imply that genetic variation is the sole determinant of trait differences between individuals. Environmental factors, gene-environment interactions, epigenetic modifications, and other biological processes contribute to the complexity of trait expression and variation in populations.