41. Why would it be unwise to place the back of your hand against the outfield wall when catching a long fly ball?

Physics · Middle School · Thu Feb 04 2021

Answered on

 It would be unwise to place the back of your hand against the outfield wall when catching a long fly ball for a few reasons. Firstly, positioning your hand this way would make it harder for you to catch the ball securely, as the back of the hand is not as concave or flexible as the palm, and it doesn't provide a good surface to grip or cradle the ball. Secondly, and more importantly, doing so increases the risk of injury. When you catch a ball moving at high speed, your hand and wrist absorb the force of the impact. If the back of your hand is against a solid surface, like a wall, you are creating a point of compression for that force, with little room for the energy to be absorbed or dispersed. This can lead to injuries such as sprains, fractures, or bruising to your hand, wrist, or even forearm, because of the impact with both the ball and the wall.

Extra: In baseball or softball, catching a fly ball is a skill that requires both coordination and knowledge of safety techniques. When outfielders track a fly ball heading towards the wall, they must be conscious of their surroundings, including the position of the wall, to avoid injury. Outfielders are trained to use techniques to maintain awareness of their proximity to the wall, such as looking for warning tracks, listening for teammates' guidance, or taking quick glances at the wall while tracking the ball.

As for the catching technique itself, players are taught to catch the ball with their fingers up (like giving a “high five”) or to the side, into the "web" of the glove, which allows the glove to absorb the impact and provides a larger, more secure surface area for the catch. Additionally, proper catching technique includes preparing to transfer the ball quickly to the throwing hand, which can be hindered if the back of the hand is against a wall upon impact.

Understanding physics can also shed light on why this is important. Upon impact, the kinetic energy from the ball needs to go somewhere. If there's a solid wall behind your hand, the energy transfer is abrupt and direct, leading to a higher force on your hand. However, if there's no wall, the energy can dissipate through the motion of the glove and arm, which can move backward upon catching, reducing the chances of injury.

Answered on

It would be unwise to place the back of your hand against the outfield wall when catching a long fly ball because this position can lead to a greater risk of injury to your hand, wrist, and arm. When you reach back to touch the wall, your hand is in a vulnerable position. If you misjudge the distance or the speed of the ball and your hand makes contact with the wall before you catch the ball, the impact could cause bruises, sprains, or even fractures. Additionally, the back of your hand is less sensitive than your fingertips, making it harder to gauge the distance to the wall accurately. Furthermore, you might obstruct the natural catching motion of your hand and arm, which could interfere with successfully catching the ball. Instead, outfielders are often trained to use the tip of their glove to feel for the wall while keeping their eyes on the ball, ensuring both safety and a better chance to make the catch.

Extra: Catching a fly ball in baseball requires a combination of hand-eye coordination, timing, and spatial awareness. Outfielders need to track the ball as it travels through the air, calculate where it is going to land, and move to that spot in time to make the catch. When an outfielder is close to the outfield wall, they must also be aware of their proximity to the wall to avoid collision or injury. Using the tip of the glove rather than the hand to find the wall allows outfielders to keep their hands and arms in a more protected and effective position for making catches. Additionally, doing so helps them maintain an appropriate body posture and balance, which are crucial for a successful and injury-free catch. Baseball players, especially those in the outfield, are trained to make these split-second judgments and physical adjustments to excel in their role and stay safe on the field.